Atlantis

Claim: Atlantis was an advanced prehistoric civilization that physically existed before sinking beneath the ocean.

Compare

Bullshit Meter

Pure ontological fiction, excluding real psychological effects.

73.6%
Hard empirical modelHeuristicHybrid pseudosciencePure fiction

Physics vs. mind loop

Does it work in the physical world, or only through belief and behaviour?

Physical world29.4%
Mind & behaviour7.1%

Neither physically real nor a meaningful psychological loop.

Bio & cult hazard

19.3%

Risk of abandoning medicine and of getting trapped in a closed group.

☣ Medical risk9.9%
🔒 Cult isolation32.3%

Topological fingerprint

The structural profile of the claim on five axes.

Empirical rigorMagic & dogmaRhetorical fogConspiracyPsychosocial
Empirical rigor
17.4%
Magic & dogma
32.5%
Rhetorical fog
24.9%
Conspiracy
22.1%
Psychosocial
7.6%
Compare with

Ockham's guillotine

What remains after cutting away the unfalsifiable superstructure.

Hard core1.3%
Common sense6.0%
Pure ritual74.1%
Empty negation18.6%

Scam & grift

18.3%

How much it works as a money-extraction funnel.

1. Bait30.9%
2. Guru dependence30.2%
3. Blaming the client0.7%

Fog & Barnum

44.4%

Protection from refutation through vagueness and stolen jargon.

Energy, frequency, vibration, quantum alignment, natural harmony, ancient wisdom, holistic balance…

  • Barnum effect32.7%
  • Motte-and-bailey53.5%
  • Stolen jargon4.8%

Guru roulette

Does the result depend on who performs it?

Not applicable

Fossil & dogma clock

97.7%

Does the field correct its errors, or is it frozen?

  1. 🚀Active science1.0%
  2. 🩹Degenerative patching46.2%
  3. 🎭Marketing chameleon11.0%
  4. 🦴Fossil in amber41.8%

Tin-foil hat reactor

23.6%

How big a global conspiracy the claim needs.

12345

Paranoia level 2/5 · A few bad actors